In this golden age of home viewing, the Criterion Collection still provides some of the best editions of the best movies ever released, usually with a rich selection of extras and often including audio commentaries (a feature they pioneered, and perhaps the greatest gift ever to film students and cinephiles alike). This column features one Criterion release per week, based entirely on where my interests lead me.
Requiem for a Heavyweight is included in the Criterion box set The Golden Age of Television. For more about that series and the context in which the programs in it were created, see this review.
Every program included in The Golden Age of Television is a master class in doing a lot with a little, creating the sense of an entire world while working within a television budget, shooting on sound stages, and performing it all live. Still, Requiem for a Heavyweight stands out as the first among equals, and demonstrates the same kind of skill writer Rod Serling would later display in The Twilight Zone to create tightly-crafted stories that can be shot on a television production schedule but produce a result that looks a whole lot bigger than their budget.
One thing you need to know to appreciate Requiem for a Heavyweight is that boxing used to be a major professional sport in the United States so the milieu of the story would be familiar to most Americans. Boxing was also featured in many movies of the 1940s and 1950s (note the distribution in this chronological list) which is not surprising given the built-in drama of the battles in the ring coupled with the offstage drama of the betting action. In those days, if you like your sport clean and sunny and played on grass fields, there was baseball; if you preferred grit and bloodshed and guys with crooked noses, there was boxing.
I was surprised on this rewatch to discover that there is no boxing action in Requiem for a Heavyweight, which is a compliment to Serling’s and director Ralph Nelson’s ability to imply through dialog and setting what you don’t see on the screen. The story begins just after Harlan “Mountain” McClintock (Jack Palance in a rare sympathetic role) has lost badly to a young up-and-comer and is nearly carried back to the locker room by his manager Maish (Keenan Wynn) and cut man Army (Ed Wynn, Keenan’s dad). Mountain’s face is an ungodly mess and doesn’t take the doctor (Edgar Stehli) long to arrive at the conclusion that his career is over, since he’s already suffered enough eye damage that a few good blows could leave him completely blind. Too bad Mountain is just 33, doesn’t know how to do anything else, shows signs of punchiness and was maybe not the brightest of guys to begin with.
Maish has troubles of his own—he bet against his own fighter and lost (the bet was about how many rounds Mountain would last) and now he owes money to someone not noted for his patience in financial matters. And he’s just lost his source of income. But he has an idea that could solve both his and Mountain’s problems: Mountain can go on the professional wrestling circuit playing a goofy hillbilly character. Despite his desperate circumstances, Mountain finds the idea repulsive—he’s a fighter, not a clown, and doesn’t want to sell his dignity for a fast buck. Yet he has a lot of years left to live and doing nothing is not an option.
Palance’s performance is a revelation. He usually played bad guys in film noirs and Westerns (playing against type in City Slickers (1991) may help explain his improbable Oscar). In Requiem for a Heavyweight he’s a kind of Holy Innocent who doesn’t understand the world in which he lives and, even when facing the abyss himself, is concerned about having caused trouble to the manager who has mercilessly exploited him and wants to continue to do so. I know that sounds corny as anything but Palance pulls it off convincingly and you can’t help but cheer for him. Ed Wynn also comes through with a heartfelt performance as someone who does know he works in a dirty business but has chosen to retain his humanity. | Sarah Boslaugh
Spine #: 495
Technical details: 72 min.; B&W; screen ratio 1.33:1; English.
Edition reviewed: DVD (3 discs).
Extras: Introduction hosted by Jack Klugman for the 1981 PBS television series The Golden Age of Television and including interviews with director Ralph Nelson, producer Martin Manulis, actors Jack Palance and Keenan Wynn, and Carol Serling (Rod’s wife); audio commentary by director Ralph Nelson (for the first five chapters only). The Criterion web site mentions a booklet including an essay by Ron Simon and liner notes for each program but it was missing from the library copy I reviewed.
Fun Fact: Ed Wynn had a long and successful career as a comedian (dating back to the days of vaudeville) before switching to dramatic in the mid-1950s at the urging of his son Keenan. The saying “all beginnings are difficult” applies here because Wynn had so much trouble remembering his lines that he was almost fired from Requiem for a Heavyweight. He pulled it together for the live performance, however, and would go on to become a respected dramatic actor nominated for an Academy Award his role in The Diary of Anne Frank (1959).
Fun Fact #2: Requiem for a Heavyweight was the first 90-minute (with commercials) live drama shown on television.
Parting Thought: Rod Serling and Ralph Nelson, writer and director of this version of Requiem for a Heavyweight, also created the 1962 film starring Anthony Quinn. That version of the story is much grimmer, particularly in its conclusion. We know Serling often fought (usually in vain) television censorship, so is the 1962 version a truer version of what he would have preferred to produce in 1956, or is it just a different take one the same story?
