Paweł Pawlikowski is one of my favorite directors working today. His delicate character studies surrounding significant world events are so quietly rich and layered that they age brilliantly. Fatherland — the third in a thematic trilogy, preceded by Ida and Cold War — is so delicate that it ends up feeling rather slight in comparison to others of Pawlikowski’s films, but by no means does that make it a failure. It’s a singular character study of real-life German writer Thomas Mann (Hanns Zischler) and his daughter Erika (Sandra Hüller) as they travel postwar Germany in 1949.
Thomas is being honored by several different institutions and groups as part of a speaking tour. He fled Germany in 1933, choosing to reside in Switzerland after the Nazis came to power. When war broke out in 1939, he moved again to the United States. This is the first time he has been back to Germany since then, and over the course of his travels, he and Erika become exhausted from how often he is treated as a prop for whatever new nationalistic jingoisms have been adopted in whichever region. Erika is kind of the audience avatar here, since Thomas rarely makes his true feelings known, at least verbally. She interacts with several people she knew in the past, and that informs hers and her father’s anxieties about the future.
The travelogue quality to the film makes it feel less introspective than Ida and less epic than Cold War. Perhaps it’s unfair to only compare Pawlikowski’s new work to his old work, but with all three films being under 90 minutes and often so understated, it really is difficult not to compare them to each other. In any event, I don’t think Fatherland makes as much use of its brief runtime as perhaps it could. Due to the film’s briskness, every new sub-theme introduced gets only one scene to shine. I don’t need a great filmmaker like Pawlikowski to get repetitive, but at the same time, I wish the film overall stopped to breathe as much as I know his films can. However, that’s perhaps intentional, since Thomas and Erika begin to feel as though they’re constantly being whisked away to the next presentation on their journey. The difficult part for me is that the destination felt like the journey here because the end of the journey came so quickly.
Again, none of this is to say that the film isn’t very strong in its own right or isn’t worth seeing. Hüller, who has been on a tear in the past few years in so many great films, is excellent again here. As I alluded to before, hers is the much more explosive performance, and it’s genuinely satisfying when Erika explodes at the fascists who prize her father’s existence merely for their own selfish ends. Zischler is understated, but devastating at points. Through him, Pawlikowski hints at a previous culture which was forever lost to sheer evil and barbarism. I would say I hope we never repeat the kinds of evils lamented through the ghosts haunting this film, but sadly, we seem to consistently make similar ghosts every day. May there come a day when we will not have to take so many journeys of repentance. | George Napper
